A personal injury intake call should capture five things: who is calling and how to reach them, when and where the accident happened, whether they were hurt, whether they have seen a doctor, and what they want a lawyer to answer. Everything else a caller asks for — a view on fault, a number, a deadline, advice about the insurer — goes into the message for a lawyer, never into the receptionist’s reply.
The general rules for a law firm’s phone are already set out on this site. AI phone answering for law firm intake covers the three hard lines every firm needs (no advice, no conflict check, no implied representation), and virtual receptionist for a small law firm covers the rest of the phone — existing clients, opposing counsel, court staff. This page assumes both and deals with the calls that only a personal injury practice gets: the accident that happened this morning, the caller who has just hung up on an adjuster, the records request, the injury question, and the fee question.
For transparency: Reign AI builds an AI receptionist for law firms on human-grade voice AI, so we have a stake in how these calls are handled. Everything below applies equally to a person answering the firm’s phone.
The accident-was-today call
When a caller says the accident happened today, take their name and callback number first, then when and where it happened, and nothing more than the call needs. If they are still at the scene and anyone is hurt or in danger, they should be told to call 911 first — and only an instruction the firm writes into the setup will make that happen.
Personal injury firms get calls that no other practice gets: someone ringing from the side of the road, from a hospital waiting room, or from the parking lot of a store where they have just fallen. The caller is shaken and often in pain, and the call can drop at any moment. That is why the contact details come first. A call that ends after thirty seconds with a name and a number is a call the firm can return; one that ends after five minutes of detail and no number is not.
A receptionist is not an emergency service, and nothing built into it tells a caller to call 911. What it does with a caller at the scene depends on how the firm has set it up:
- With live transfer switched on, it asks one fixed question when a caller might be describing an emergency happening right now: “Is this an emergency right now, or is it something that can wait until the next business day?” A clear “yes, right now” rings the firm’s transfer number. That suits a contractor with a burst pipe; for a personal injury firm it means ringing a lawyer about an injury that is happening now, which is usually not what the firm wants.
- Without live transfer, no question is asked and the call becomes a message, like any other.
So a personal injury firm should write its own instruction into the receptionist’s setup: a caller who is hurt or in danger right now is told to call 911 first — before the name, before the intake, before anything. The receptionist cannot judge how badly anyone is hurt, so the instruction has to be the same every time. That is the firm’s decision and the firm’s configuration, and it needs testing with live transfer switched on, so you can hear the caller told to call 911 rather than put through. The emergency question for trades is covered in how an AI receptionist handles emergency calls after hours; for a law firm the real emergencies belong to 911, not to anyone at the firm.
A sample call
An illustrative example, not a recording of a real call. It assumes an Ontario firm that has not switched on live transfer, so the emergency question is never asked and every call becomes a message for a lawyer.
Receptionist: Thank you for calling [Firm name]. This call may be recorded for quality and training purposes. How can I help you?
Caller: I was in a car accident this morning. I’m at the hospital now and someone said I should call a lawyer.
Receptionist: I’m sorry that happened. Are you somewhere safe right now?
Caller: Yes, I’m in the waiting room.
Receptionist: Good. I’ll take a few details so a lawyer can review this. Can I get your name?
Caller: (Gives their name.)
Receptionist: Thank you. What’s the best number to reach you?
Caller: (Gives a number.)
Receptionist: And where did the accident happen?
Caller: At an intersection in Mississauga. The other driver went through a red light.
Receptionist: I’ve noted that. Were you hurt?
Caller: My neck and shoulder are sore. They’re checking me now.
Receptionist: I’ll include that. Is there anything you’d like to ask the lawyer?
Caller: The other driver’s insurance company already called me. Should I talk to them?
Receptionist: That’s a question for a lawyer, so I’ve written it down in your words and put it at the top of your message. Is there anything else the lawyer should know?
Caller: No, that’s it.
Receptionist: A lawyer at the firm will review this, and someone will be in touch about whether the firm can help. Thank you for calling.
The firm receives a summary by email, or by Telegram if it has been connected: the caller’s name and number, that the accident happened this morning at an intersection in Mississauga, that they were hurt and are being seen at a hospital, and their question about the insurer, in their words. The receptionist did not say the other driver was at fault, did not say the caller had a case, gave no view on the insurer, and did not suggest the firm had taken them on.
Why the date question matters
The date of the accident is the single most useful fact on a personal injury message, because it is what lets a lawyer decide how quickly the file needs attention. The receptionist’s only job is to record it accurately — never to say what the date means.
The law firm intake page makes the general point that the date question should be asked on every call. The personal injury version has two wrinkles.
Callers are often vague, and that is fine. “Sometime last winter”, “a few months ago”, “the week after the long weekend” — slip-and-fall and long-ago callers rarely have an exact date. The receptionist should take what the caller says, in their words, and not push them into guessing a day they do not know. A wrong date written down as fact is worse than an honest “last winter”.
The receptionist never comments on the date. No “that’s still recent”, no “you should be fine”, no “you may have left it late”. Every one of those is a view on a time limit, and time limits are exactly what the caller cannot afford to be wrong about. Any deadline that applies is for a lawyer to work out from the full facts, and the receptionist says only that the date has been noted for the lawyer.
The same goes for where it happened. The place matters to the lawyer for reasons that are the lawyer’s to explain, so it is recorded — the city, the road or the store — and not discussed.
“Should I talk to the adjuster?”
Whether to speak to an insurance adjuster is a question for a lawyer, so the receptionist never answers it. It writes the question down in the caller’s words and puts it at the top of the message, because for many callers it is the reason they rang.
The trap here is that the helpful-sounding answers are all advice. “Don’t say anything until you’ve spoken to a lawyer”, “it’s fine to give them the basics”, “don’t sign anything” — each one tells the caller how to act on their claim, and the firm has not yet agreed to act for them. The receptionist’s answer is the same every time: that is a question for a lawyer, it is at the top of your message, and a lawyer will see it.
Adjusters calling the firm are a different call. An insurer’s representative ringing about a person is a third party, exactly like opposing counsel: take an accurate message, route it to the right lawyer, and say nothing else — not whether the person is a client, not whether a lawyer is in, nothing about the matter. How a receptionist should handle the other side’s office is set out in the opposing-counsel answer on virtual receptionist for a small law firm, and it applies to adjusters word for word.
Medical-records and records-office calls
A call from a hospital records department, a clinic, an employer or another firm about records or paperwork is routed or taken as a message — never answered from a file. The receptionist does not read anything out, does not confirm what the firm holds, and does not confirm that the person is a client.
Personal injury files run on paperwork that other offices send in and chase up: records requests, authorizations, invoices for reports, questions about a release form. The person calling usually wants to speak to whoever handles that file. The setup should know who that is, route the call there where live transfer is set up (otherwise it becomes a message), and take a message when that person is not available — with the caller’s name, organisation, number and what they need.
What it must not do is helpful-sounding confirmation. “Yes, we act for her” confirms a relationship to a stranger; “we got those last week” discloses what is on a file. The receptionist has no access to the firm’s files, and for these calls it does not need any.
The client’s own version of this call — “did you get my records?” — is a status call, and is handled the way the status-update call on the small-firm page describes: capture the question against the right file and promise a callback, without confirming anything about the file’s contents.
Capture as little health information as possible
Two questions are enough on a first call, “Were you hurt?” and “Have you seen a doctor about it?”, with the answers taken down in the caller’s words. The receptionist never runs through a list of symptoms, never comments on an injury, and never suggests what the caller should do about it.
This is a law firm’s phone, and the lawyer will take a full history in an interview, with the right questions and the right confidentiality. A phone message is the wrong place for that detail: it lands in an inbox, it may be read by more than one person, and everything in it is sensitive personal information the firm is now responsible for. The less it carries, the less there is to protect.
So the intake is deliberately short:
- Were you hurt? Yes, no, or the caller’s own short description.
- Have you seen a doctor about it? Yes, no, or where they are being seen.
- Nothing else. No list of body parts, no pain scale, no treatment history, no “have you had this before”.
Callers will sometimes describe their injuries at length, and that is fine — the receptionist listens, records the gist in the caller’s words, and moves on. What it never does is offer an opinion, even a kind one: “that sounds serious”, “you should get that looked at” and “you’ll be fine” are all comments it is not in a position to make. Where those messages are stored and who can read them are questions to settle in writing before signing with anyone; the questions to ask are in the confidentiality section of the intake page.
The fee question
When a caller asks how fees work, the receptionist gives the firm’s own approved sentence, word for word, and nothing else. It never states a percentage, a figure or a slogan, and never improvises an explanation of a fee arrangement.
“Do you work on a percentage?” and “do I have to pay anything up front?” are among the most common questions on a personal injury line, and they are the easiest to get wrong. A receptionist that fills the gap with a number, a percentage or a catchy phrase has made a statement about the firm’s terms that a lawyer then has to stand behind or walk back.
The fix is to write the answer once. The firm decides the sentence — for example, “A lawyer will explain how fees work before you agree to anything” — and the receptionist says exactly that. If the firm has not written one, the question goes into the message, at the top, for a lawyer to answer on the callback. Either way the caller hears something true, and nothing the firm did not choose to say.
Test it with a pushy caller
Call the setup yourself and play the caller who will not take no for an answer. It should hold every line below, every time, and still end the call with a complete message.
Personal injury callers push harder than most, and for understandable reasons: they are hurt, worried about money and talking to an insurer. Run one call and ask, in this order:
- “Do I have a case?” It should decline to say and keep collecting facts.
- “Whose fault was it, honestly?” No view, however the question is put.
- “Roughly what’s it worth?” No number, no range, no “it depends on…” that turns into one.
- “Am I too late?” No comment on any deadline; the date is noted for a lawyer.
- “Should I talk to the adjuster?” Written down as a question for a lawyer, not answered.
- “Do you take a percentage?” Your approved sentence, word for word, or a note for the lawyer.
- “So you’re my lawyer now?” No — a lawyer will review the details and someone will be in touch about whether the firm can help.
- “I’m still at the scene and my passenger is hurt.” It should tell you to call 911 before anything else, not put you through to a lawyer. It does that only if the firm has written the instruction into its setup, so run this one with live transfer switched on if the firm uses it.
Then read the message that arrives. It should carry your name and number, the date and place in your words, the two injury answers, and every question you asked, with nothing the receptionist said about fault, value or deadlines — because it said nothing about them. If it promised a callback time, check that the firm will actually keep it. For the rest of the firm’s calls — existing clients, the other side’s office, logistics — run the five-call test on the small-firm page as well.
A few things this does not change. If the firm sets up live transfer, a caller who asks to speak to a lawyer is rung through first, before anything is collected, and taken as a message only if nobody picks up — and so is a caller who answers yes to the emergency question, which is why the 911 instruction above matters. Without live transfer, every call becomes a message. The receptionist answers in English. And for firms whose callers are very often in distress, the honest case for keeping a person on the front line during the day is in when a person is still the right front line. In Canada, what a caller has to be told about recording, and where recordings may be kept, is covered in the Canadian guide.
Common questions
Should the receptionist tell a caller whether to talk to the insurance adjuster?
No. Whether to speak to an adjuster, what to say and whether to sign anything are questions for a lawyer, and any answer the receptionist gave would be advice. The right handling is to treat it as the caller's most important question: write it down in their words, put it at the top of the message, and tell them a lawyer will see it.
What does it do when someone calls from the scene of an accident?
Only what the firm has set it up to do, and nothing built in tells a caller to call 911. Where live transfer is switched on, it asks one fixed question — "Is this an emergency right now, or is it something that can wait until the next business day?" — and a clear "yes, right now" rings the firm, which for a personal injury firm means ringing a lawyer about an injury happening now. Without live transfer, no question is asked and the call becomes a message. A firm should write its own instruction into the setup telling a caller who is hurt or in danger right now to call 911 first, then test it with live transfer switched on.
What should it say when an insurance adjuster calls the firm?
Nothing about the person or the claim. An adjuster ringing the firm is a third party, like the other side's lawyer: the receptionist takes their name, company, number and what they are calling about, and passes the message to the right lawyer. It does not say whether the person is a client or whether a lawyer is in, gives no advice and mentions no deadline.
What if the caller does not know the exact date of the accident?
That is fine. The receptionist takes what the caller can say — "last winter", "a few weeks ago" — in their own words, and does not push them into guessing a day. It never says whether the timing is a problem; any deadline is for a lawyer to work out from the full facts.
How much should it ask about the caller's injuries?
As little as possible: whether they were hurt, and whether they have seen a doctor about it. The answers go into the message in the caller's words. A list of symptoms, body parts or treatments belongs in a lawyer's interview, not a phone message sitting in an inbox, and the receptionist never comments on an injury or suggests what the caller should do about it.
Can it answer "do you work on a percentage?" or "what does it cost?"
Only with the sentence the firm has approved, word for word. It never states a percentage, a figure or a slogan, and never improvises an explanation of how a fee arrangement works. If the firm has not written that sentence, the question goes into the message for a lawyer to answer.